Menu of Uncle Leo's South Shore Pita Grill in Island Park, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Uncle Leo's South Shore Pita Grill, nestled in Island Park, NY, is a refreshing revival of a beloved local classic, formerly known as Pete’s. This Greek restaurant masterfully delivers authentic flavors through a menu brimming with traditional favorites and vibrant, fresh ingredients. The moment you taste their food, it becomes clear why this spot has garnered such loyal praise and heartfelt nostalgia.

The Greek Salad Platters are notable for their freshness and balance. The Small Greek Salad with Pita embodies simplicity with crisp cucumbers, ripe tomatoes, kalamata olives, and generous crumbles of feta, all kissed by a tangy dressing. For a heartier option, the Spinach Pie with Greek Salad pairs a crisp, buttery filo crust filled with savory spinach and feta alongside the same bright salad and a side of Peter and white sauce—an unbeatable combination that respects tradition while adding a unique flair.

Meat lovers will find delight in the Charbroiled Pork Plate, where succulent pork skewers meet crispy fries, and a warm pita envelops fluffy tzatziki and white sauce, delivering a perfect blend of textures and flavors. The Chicken Gyro Plate offers tender, well-seasoned gyro meat nestled next to a fresh Greek salad, striking the ideal harmony between savory and refreshing.

Finger foods such as battered onion rings and cheddar jalapeño poppers offer crispy, flavorful bites that complement the meal without overwhelming the palate. Noteworthy is the Chicken Tenders & Fries, which are tender and cooked to a satisfying golden brown, making them a comforting choice for any diner.

Vegetarian options shine here as well. The veggie patty platter, praised by customers for its size and flavor, comes with creamy hummus and a robust Greek salad topped generously with feta cheese. The warm pita bread surrounding the veggie patties enhances the experience, offering both substance and a welcoming texture. The spinach pie, another vegetarian favorite, consistently earns accolades for its flaky crust and rich filling.

Community favorites such as the moussaka and falafel platter also make a strong impression. The moussaka evokes old-world comfort with layers of eggplant, seasoned meat, and creamy béchamel, while the falafel captures the perfect crispiness described by diners as the best they’ve had. Sides like lemon potatoes and rice pilaf stand out for their buttery, savory profiles, rounding out meals that are generous in both portion and flavor.

Consistent praise for the quality and care in preparation is echoed across reviews. Customers appreciate not only the authentic and delicious dishes but also the hospitality of Leo and his team. This spirit of warmth and attentiveness elevates the entire dining experience, making each visit or order a pleasant one.

In sum, Uncle Leo's South Shore Pita Grill offers an exceptional menu that balances tradition with freshness, hearty flavors with light sides, and meat-centric dishes with well-crafted vegetarian options. Whether you're seeking nostalgia or new favorites, this restaurant delivers with a welcoming smile and dishes that make your taste buds sing.